The awkward truth about school-gate friendships nobody really prepares mums for

The WhatsApp groups are buzzing, coffee friendships are forming and everyone else seems to know each other. Here’s why school-gate cliques can feel so surprisingly brutal.

Published: September 7, 2026 at 12:00 PM

Save

A week into the new school year, your child may already be talking about new friends. Meanwhile, you might be wondering why all the other parents seem to have found theirs too.

Ad

There you are, hovering at the school gate, attempting tentative pick-up small talk while simultaneously trying to remember which parent belongs to which child. Then comes the class WhatsApp, the first birthday invitations and the slightly alarming realisation that some parents already appear to know everyone.

For some mums, these relationships happen naturally. For others, those first few weeks can bring back surprisingly adolescent feelings: Does everyone already have a group? Should I join that conversation? Was everyone invited for coffee except me? If you're feeling it this September, you're far from alone.

The other first-day nerves nobody talks about

I've discovered that becoming a parent repeatedly puts you into social situations where you're expected to form friendships simply because your children happen to be the same age.

My first experience of this came after a complicated journey to motherhood. Before having my daughter in 2022, I'd spent four years undergoing fertility treatment, including five rounds of IVF and multiple miscarriages. By the time I finally became a mum, I was desperate to join the mum circle I'd envied for so long.

I threw myself into baby yoga, massage and rhyme time, met my NCT group every Friday for coffee, downloaded Peanut and said yes to playdates I wasn't always sure I had the energy for.

Some of those women became firm friends. With others, once we'd exhausted nappies, naps and feeding, it became clear we didn't have much else in common. They were lovely people, we just weren't necessarily destined to be friends.

Then my daughter started nursery, and suddenly there was a whole new social landscape: unfamiliar faces at drop-off and pick-up, WhatsApp groups and another chance to find a community.

Almost without realising it, I'd made a new set of mum friends, bound initially by coat pegs, snack schedules and our children occupying the same room every day. This time, I got lucky. Conversations came easily, the humour felt familiar and friendship unfolded naturally rather than feeling forced.

Why becoming a parent keeps throwing us into friendship situations

Chartered psychologist Dr Louise Goddard-Crawley says there is a reason these situations can feel so emotionally loaded.

Becoming a mum often throws women together with people they might never have chosen as friends in another phase of life at a time when many women are tired, emotional and finding their feet

Chartered psychologist Dr Louise Goddard-Crawley

“We are wired to look for safety and belonging in groups, especially during big life changes. And while these connections often do turn into real friendships, when they don’t, it’s usually because the ‘selection process’ is based on chance rather than choice.

“In earlier generations, when parenting happened within smaller, more stable communities, shared roles were more likely to come with shared values. Modern motherhood doesn’t work like that. We don’t naturally feel comfortable with everyone, and that’s okay.”

Why school-gate friendships can feel particularly intense

School adds another dimension because these aren't necessarily people you'll see for a few months at baby sensory. You could be standing beside them twice a day for years.

And there are good practical reasons to be connected. There are playdates and parties to arrange, school events to navigate and those inevitable moments when somebody needs to know whether tomorrow really is PE day.

But being friendly and connected doesn't mean you need to become close friends.

You can be the parent who says hello, chats at pick-up, occasionally has a coffee and happily swaps useful information without feeling obliged to turn every school-gate acquaintance into a new best mate.

What if everyone already seems to know each other?

This can be one of the hardest parts of those first weeks. Some parents genuinely do know each other already, perhaps their children attended the same nursery, they have older siblings at the school or they live nearby.

But seeing people chatting confidently doesn't tell you how established those friendships actually are. The two mums who look like old friends by Friday might have introduced themselves on Tuesday.

Dr Goddard-Crawley says not clicking immediately can also stir up older insecurities: “Not clicking with other mums can sometimes bring up familiar feelings of exclusion or self-doubt, even when the situation itself is very different. If it feels like you haven’t found your people yet, that doesn’t mean you won’t.”

So rather than trying to "break into" an apparent group, think small. Say hello. Learn a couple of names. Ask someone's child's name. Have another conversation tomorrow. Friendships don't need to be established before the first school newsletter lands.

How to make school-mum friendships without forcing it

What if you don't click with another parent?

This is where school friendships can require a little diplomacy. You may not want a close friendship, but your children might adore each other and you're still going to meet at the gate tomorrow morning.

That doesn't require a dramatic friendship break-up. Warm, polite and boundaried is enough.

Dr Goddard-Crawley says: “If a friendship was formed quickly through proximity rather than deep connection, letting contact naturally reduce is often the kindest option for everyone involved.”

Stepping back doesn’t have to mean rejecting someone. And if someone does ask for more explanation, it’s okay to keep things brief and kind.

Chartered psychologist Dr Louise Goddard-Crawley

In other words, "our children are friends and we get on perfectly well" can be a completely successful relationship in its own right.

You don't need a school-gate best friend

September isn't a deadline for finding your people. Some school-gate relationships will remain pleasant acquaintanceships. Others may slowly turn into the people you message about World Book Day, stand beside at sports day, swap emergency pick-up favours with and, eventually, count among your closest friends.

As Dr Goddard-Crawley puts it: “Motherhood doesn’t come with a guaranteed social circle, and it doesn’t mean you should feel an instant connection with everyone you meet through it.”

Ad

Your child making a best friend doesn't mean you have to make one too. Be open, be friendly and give yourself permission to let those school-gate relationships develop at their own pace.

Authors

Kirsty Nutkins

Ad

Ad

Loading...

Ad

Loading...